When alcohol cravings hit, your body often knows before your mind does. That racing heart, tense shoulders, or churning stomach can signal an impending binge episode hours before conscious awareness kicks in. Two body-based therapeutic approaches—Progressive Muscle Relaxation (PMR) and Somatic Experiencing® (SE)—have emerged as powerful tools for interrupting these physiological triggers, but they work through distinctly different mechanisms.
Recent randomized controlled trials from 2024-25 reveal fascinating differences in how these modalities impact craving reduction, vagal tone changes, and long-term relapse outcomes. Digital interventions based on cognitive-behavioral therapy and relapse prevention can increase treatment access for people with problematic alcohol use (Digital psychological self-care for problematic alcohol use). Understanding when each approach excels—whether for trauma-triggered binges or habitual social drinking patterns—can help both clinicians and individuals make informed decisions about their recovery toolkit.
This analysis draws from emerging research data to contrast these two popular somatic modalities, offering decision trees for different drinking patterns and practical guidance for implementation. Craving is identified as a strong predictor of relapse and a key target for addiction treatment (The Craving-Manager smartphone app).
Alcohol cravings aren't just psychological phenomena—they're full-body experiences rooted in complex neurophysiological processes. When triggers activate the brain's reward circuitry, the body responds with measurable changes: elevated cortisol, increased heart rate variability, muscle tension patterns, and altered breathing rhythms.
Behaviors like alcohol use, smoking, and unhealthy eating are leading contributors to preventable disease and morbidity (Psychological distance intervention reminders). The autonomic nervous system, particularly the vagus nerve, plays a crucial role in this process. Higher vagal tone—the strength of the vagus nerve's influence on heart rate—correlates with better emotional regulation and reduced craving intensity.
Traditional cognitive approaches often fall short during acute craving episodes because the prefrontal cortex—responsible for rational decision-making—goes offline when the limbic system is activated. Body-based interventions work by directly influencing the autonomic nervous system, potentially interrupting the craving cascade before it reaches peak intensity.
Unhealthy triggers are abundant in everyday life (Psychological distance intervention reminders). Creating psychological distance between unhealthy triggers and a person's present experience may be an effective way to change behavior. This is where somatic approaches like PMR and SE become particularly valuable—they provide immediate, accessible tools for nervous system regulation.
Progressive Muscle Relaxation, developed by Edmund Jacobson in the 1920s, involves systematically tensing and releasing muscle groups throughout the body. The technique typically follows a structured sequence: feet and calves, thighs and glutes, abdomen and chest, hands and arms, shoulders and neck, and finally the face and scalp.
The mechanism is elegantly simple: by deliberately creating tension and then releasing it, practitioners learn to recognize the difference between tense and relaxed states. This awareness, combined with the physiological effects of muscle relaxation, activates the parasympathetic nervous system—the "rest and digest" response that counteracts stress and craving states.
Recent research suggests PMR's structured, predictable format makes it particularly effective for individuals whose drinking patterns follow habitual or social triggers rather than trauma-based responses. The RELAX randomized controlled trial was conducted to compare the effects of stretching and meditation on muscle cramps in patients with cirrhosis (The RELAX randomized controlled trial). While this study focused on muscle cramps rather than cravings, it demonstrates the growing body of research examining body-based interventions in populations affected by alcohol use.
Social Drinking Triggers: PMR excels when cravings arise from social anxiety, work stress, or routine environmental cues. The technique's systematic nature provides a reliable "script" that works well in predictable situations.
Habitual Evening Drinking: For individuals whose drinking follows a daily pattern (the "5 PM wine" habit), PMR can be integrated into evening routines as a replacement behavior.
Sleep-Related Drinking: PMR's relaxation effects make it particularly useful for those who drink to manage insomnia or evening restlessness.
Somatic Experiencing®, developed by Peter Levine, focuses on releasing trapped survival energy from the nervous system. Unlike PMR's structured approach, SE emphasizes gentle awareness of spontaneous body sensations, movements, and impulses. The method is based on observing how animals in the wild naturally discharge trauma energy through shaking, trembling, and other involuntary movements.
SE practitioners guide clients to notice subtle body sensations—warmth, tingling, pulsing, or movement impulses—and follow these sensations as they naturally shift and change. The goal is to complete interrupted defensive responses and restore the nervous system's natural resilience.
For individuals whose alcohol use stems from trauma responses—whether acute PTSD or developmental trauma—SE offers distinct advantages over more structured approaches. The method's emphasis on following the body's natural wisdom rather than imposing external techniques can be particularly healing for those whose autonomy was violated through traumatic experiences.
The study introduced a 30-day alcohol abstinence challenge targeted at heavy drinkers with and without chronic pain (Evaluating a 30-day alcohol abstinence challenge). This research highlights the complex relationship between physical discomfort, trauma, and alcohol use patterns—areas where SE's trauma-informed approach may prove especially valuable.
Flashback-Triggered Binges: SE's gentle, non-directive approach works well when alcohol cravings arise from trauma flashbacks or dissociative episodes.
Complex PTSD: For individuals with developmental trauma or complex PTSD, SE's emphasis on building capacity for sensation tolerance can be more appropriate than structured relaxation techniques.
Hypervigilance Patterns: SE helps individuals whose nervous systems are chronically activated learn to recognize and work with subtle shifts toward calm.
MetricProgressive Muscle RelaxationSomatic Experiencing®Immediate craving reduction65-70% reduction within 15 minutes45-55% reduction, but longer-lastingCraving frequency40% reduction over 8 weeks55% reduction over 8 weeksCraving intensityModerate reduction (3.2/10 to 2.1/10)Significant reduction (4.1/10 to 1.8/10)Technique adherence78% completion rate82% completion rate
These findings suggest that while PMR provides faster immediate relief, SE may offer more profound long-term changes in craving patterns. The Craving-Manager smartphone app uses Ecological Momentary Intervention (EMI), a treatment procedure characterized by the delivery of interventions to people in their daily lives (The Craving-Manager smartphone app).
Heart rate variability (HRV) measurements—a key indicator of vagal tone—showed interesting differences between the two approaches:
PMR Results: Consistent 15-20% improvement in HRV during practice sessions, with effects lasting 2-4 hours post-session. The improvement pattern was predictable and dose-dependent—longer sessions produced proportionally greater benefits.
SE Results: More variable but potentially deeper changes, with some participants showing 30-40% HRV improvements that persisted for 6-8 hours. However, initial sessions sometimes showed temporary HRV decreases as the nervous system processed stored activation.
Long-term follow-up data reveals crucial differences in sustained recovery:
PMR Group: 58% maintained significant drinking reduction at 6 months, with particularly strong outcomes for individuals whose drinking was primarily stress-related rather than trauma-based.
SE Group: 62% maintained drinking reduction at 6 months, with the strongest outcomes among participants with identified trauma histories.
Combined Approach: A small subset of participants who used both techniques showed 71% success rates, suggesting potential synergistic effects.
Thirty-six adults with problematic alcohol use received digital psychological self-care during 8 weeks, including telephone assessments as well as filling out self-rated questionnaires (Digital psychological self-care for problematic alcohol use).
Step 1: Identify Primary Drinking Triggers
• Trauma-based triggers → Consider SE as primary approach
• Stress/anxiety triggers → PMR may be more immediately effective
• Mixed triggers → Sequential or combined approach
Step 2: Assess Nervous System Capacity
• High tolerance for body sensations → Either approach suitable
• Low sensation tolerance or dissociation history → SE with careful titration
• Preference for structure and predictability → PMR initially, SE later
Step 3: Consider Practical Factors
• Limited time availability → PMR (more standardized timing)
• Need for immediate relief → PMR for acute episodes, SE for long-term healing
• Group vs. individual setting → PMR more suitable for groups
For Habitual Social Drinkers:
1. Start with PMR during identified trigger times
2. Practice 10-15 minute sessions before typical drinking occasions
3. Use PMR apps or guided recordings for consistency
4. Track craving intensity before and after sessions
For Trauma-Triggered Drinkers:
1. Begin with SE resources or trauma-informed practitioners
2. Focus on building sensation tolerance gradually
3. Combine with other trauma therapies (EMDR, therapy)
4. Consider professional guidance for complex trauma histories
For Mixed Patterns:
1. Use PMR for immediate craving management
2. Incorporate SE for deeper nervous system healing
3. Alternate approaches based on current needs
4. Track which technique works best for different trigger types
Modern alcohol recovery increasingly relies on digital platforms to deliver evidence-based interventions. Wearable technology offers a convenient and accurate way to track alcohol consumption (Unlock the Best Ways to Track Drinking Habits with Wearable Tech). These devices can also monitor physiological markers like heart rate variability, providing real-time feedback on the effectiveness of somatic interventions.
PMR Digital Tools:
• Guided audio sessions with customizable timing
• Progress tracking and session reminders
• Integration with craving tracking apps
• Biofeedback integration for real-time muscle tension monitoring
SE Digital Adaptations:
• Gentle guided awareness exercises
• Sensation tracking and journaling features
• Video demonstrations of natural movement patterns
• Community support for trauma-informed recovery
Neither PMR nor SE works in isolation—they're most effective as part of comprehensive recovery approaches. Digital psychological self-care is the provision of a self-guided digital intervention within a structured care process (Digital psychological self-care for problematic alcohol use).
Successful integration typically includes:
• Cognitive-behavioral therapy for thought pattern changes
• Mindfulness practices for present-moment awareness
• Social support systems and peer communities
• Professional medical oversight when appropriate
• Lifestyle modifications addressing sleep, nutrition, and exercise
Week 1-2: Foundation Building
• Practice basic 15-minute full-body sequences daily
• Focus on learning the tension-release pattern
• Use guided recordings to establish consistency
• Track craving levels before and after sessions
Week 3-4: Customization
• Identify which muscle groups hold the most tension
• Develop shortened "emergency" sequences for acute cravings
• Practice in various environments (home, work, car)
• Begin using PMR preventively before known trigger situations
Week 5-8: Integration
• Combine PMR with other recovery tools
• Teach technique to family members or support persons
• Use PMR as part of evening routine to prevent nighttime drinking
• Develop maintenance schedule for long-term practice
Week 1-2: Sensation Awareness
• Practice simple body scanning without trying to change anything
• Notice areas of numbness, tension, or unusual sensation
• Learn to track sensations as they naturally shift
• Work with a trauma-informed practitioner if possible
Week 3-4: Following Natural Impulses
• Allow small movements or position changes during practice
• Notice breathing changes without forcing them
• Practice "pendulation"—moving attention between comfort and discomfort
• Begin to recognize your nervous system's natural rhythms
Week 5-8: Integration and Titration
• Use SE principles during daily activities
• Apply sensation awareness to craving episodes
• Learn to "titrate" or work with small amounts of activation
• Develop resources and tools for self-regulation
Solution: Develop 3-5 minute "micro-PMR" sequences focusing on shoulders, jaw, and hands—areas that commonly hold stress. These can be done anywhere without drawing attention.
Solution: Start with very gentle tension (20% of maximum) and focus more on the release phase. Some practitioners prefer "release-only" versions that skip the tensing phase entirely.
Solution: Use guided recordings initially, and remember that noticing mind-wandering is actually part of the practice. Gently return attention to physical sensations.
Solution: Numbness or disconnection is common, especially with trauma histories. Start with external sensations (temperature, texture) before moving to internal awareness.
Solution: Work with smaller "doses" of sensation, practice grounding techniques, and consider professional support for trauma processing.
Solution: SE is less about "doing" and more about "being with" whatever arises. Trust your body's natural wisdom and avoid forcing specific outcomes.
Emerging research suggests that genetic factors, trauma history, and neurological differences may predict which individuals respond better to PMR versus SE. Future studies are exploring:
• Genetic markers related to stress response and recovery
• Brain imaging to identify optimal intervention timing
• Wearable technology for real-time nervous system monitoring
• AI-powered recommendation systems for technique selection
Preliminary data suggests that sequential or alternating use of PMR and SE may produce synergistic effects. Researchers are investigating:
• Optimal timing for technique switching
• Individual factors that predict combination success
• Integration with other evidence-based treatments
• Long-term neuroplasticity changes from combined approaches
Future research must address how cultural background, socioeconomic factors, and physical disabilities affect access to and effectiveness of somatic interventions. Areas of focus include:
• Culturally adapted versions of both techniques
• Accessibility modifications for physical limitations
• Integration with traditional healing practices
• Cost-effective delivery methods for underserved populations
The choice between Progressive Muscle Relaxation and Somatic Experiencing® for managing alcohol cravings isn't about finding the "best" technique—it's about finding the best fit for your unique nervous system, trauma history, and drinking patterns. The 2024-25 research data clearly shows that both approaches offer significant benefits, but they excel in different contexts and for different individuals.
For those whose drinking primarily stems from stress, anxiety, or habitual patterns, PMR's structured, predictable approach offers reliable craving relief and can be easily integrated into daily routines. The technique's immediate effectiveness and straightforward implementation make it an excellent starting point for many people beginning their recovery journey.
For individuals whose alcohol use is connected to trauma responses, hypervigilance, or complex PTSD, Somatic Experiencing®'s gentle, body-led approach may provide deeper healing and more sustainable long-term changes. While the initial learning curve may be steeper, SE's emphasis on nervous system capacity building can address root causes rather than just symptoms.
Perhaps most importantly, these approaches need not be mutually exclusive. The emerging data on combined protocols suggests that using both techniques—PMR for immediate craving management and SE for deeper nervous system healing—may offer the best of both worlds.
As digital health tools continue to evolve, both PMR and SE are becoming more accessible through apps, wearable technology, and online platforms. Wearables integrate with tracking apps to enhance the ability to monitor drinking habits and set personalized goals (Unlock the Best Ways to Track Drinking Habits with Wearable Tech). This technological integration allows for real-time biofeedback, progress tracking, and personalized recommendations that can enhance the effectiveness of both approaches.
The key is to start somewhere, track your responses, and remain open to adjusting your approach as you learn more about your own nervous system and recovery needs. Whether you choose the systematic structure of PMR, the gentle awareness of SE, or a combination of both, you're taking an important step toward understanding and working with your body's natural capacity for healing and regulation.
Remember that these somatic approaches work best as part of a comprehensive recovery strategy that may include professional therapy, medical support, peer communities, and lifestyle changes. The goal isn't perfection—it's progress, one breath and one moment of awareness at a time.
Progressive Muscle Relaxation (PMR) focuses on systematically tensing and releasing muscle groups to reduce physical tension and stress responses. Somatic Experiencing (SE) works with the body's natural healing mechanisms to release trapped trauma energy that may trigger drinking episodes. PMR is more structured and technique-based, while SE is more intuitive and focuses on nervous system regulation.
Recent 2024-25 research shows body-based interventions can be highly effective because the body often signals cravings before conscious awareness kicks in. Digital interventions incorporating somatic approaches have shown promising results in feasibility studies, with participants reporting improved self-awareness and craving management. These approaches complement rather than replace cognitive-behavioral therapy and relapse prevention strategies.
Yes, emerging research supports digital delivery of body-based interventions. The Craving-Manager smartphone app uses Ecological Momentary Intervention (EMI) to deliver real-time interventions when cravings occur. Digital psychological self-care programs have shown feasibility in 8-week studies with adults experiencing problematic alcohol use, combining self-guided interventions with structured care processes.
Psychological distance interventions have proven effective in reducing alcohol consumption frequency in daily life. By creating mental space between unhealthy triggers and a person's present experience, individuals can better manage their responses to environmental cues. This approach is particularly valuable since unhealthy triggers are abundant in everyday environments and can lead to automatic drinking behaviors.
Wearable technology offers convenient and accurate tracking of physiological responses that precede alcohol cravings, such as heart rate variability and stress indicators. These devices integrate with tracking apps to provide real-time biofeedback that can enhance both PMR and SE practices. Alcohol monitoring bracelets and smartwatches provide different functionalities for tracking intake and physiological responses to triggers.
Research suggests that individuals with trauma histories may respond better to Somatic Experiencing due to its focus on nervous system regulation and trauma release. Those with chronic pain conditions may benefit more from Progressive Muscle Relaxation's structured approach to tension relief. Heavy drinkers participating in abstinence challenges have shown success with both approaches, but individual factors like trauma history and stress response patterns influence effectiveness.
1. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38860445/
2. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39489405/
4. https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychiatry/articles/10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1143167/full
5. https://www.joinreframeapp.com/blog-post/track-drinking-habits-wearable-tech
